Want to listen on Apple Podcasts or Spotify? Click on the SHARE (next to more info) option below and Enjoy!
Has December ever felt like one long pop quiz for your relationship? Maybe you’ve been hinting about a gift since October (a not-so-subtle screenshot here, a “wow, that’s cute” there). Maybe you’ve been quietly picturing his mom’s living room, the ornaments, and the photo by the tree while you wait for an invitation to Christmas dinner. Or maybe all you want is a text on Christmas morning. The holidays turn every gesture into evidence, and if you have an anxious attachment style, your body is reading every single one.
Then the moment comes and he misses it. The gift card shows up, the invite never comes, the text arrives at 4pm, and suddenly you’re asking the question so many women ask me this time of year: should I tell him I’m hurt? Good news, there’s a way to answer that question long before it becomes a problem. (Spoiler: it involves a list. Santa was onto something.)
How Anxious Attachment Turns the Holidays Into a Test
When we want something and keep it to ourselves, we start waiting for him to just know. That could be the invitation, the thoughtful gift, or the midnight kiss on New Year’s Eve. Waiting feels harmless, and it quietly sets up a pass or fail moment your partner has no idea is happening. He can’t pass a test he never knew he was taking, so the hurt lands on you, the resentment builds, and eventually what he hears is disappointment. Closeness slips further away, which is the very thing you were hoping for in the first place.
So why does this happen? Mary Ainsworth, building on John Bowlby’s work, did a study watching how babies reacted when their mothers left the room and came back. She found that babies whose caregivers showed up inconsistently stayed on high alert, watching closely and struggling to settle. Our earliest relationships teach us whether the people we love will reliably show up. If love felt inconsistent growing up, your nervous system learned to scan for signs that you matter. And the holidays? Oh, they’re a buffet of signs. Every gift, plan, and invitation becomes proof of where you stand (no wonder you’re exhausted by December 15th).
Why Saying It Early Works (Even Santa Needs a List)
Kids have this figured out. They write the list, mail it to the North Pole, and tell every mall Santa within a fifty-mile radius exactly what they want. Nobody sits by the tree on Christmas morning fuming that Santa skipped something they never wrote down. Somewhere along the way, we grown women stopped writing the list and kept expecting the presents anyway. 🎁
Here’s the beautiful part. If you’re the woman asking “should I tell him I’m hurt,” you’re probably also the woman who remembers everyone’s favorite pie and pulls the awkward cousin by the snack table into the conversation. Your radar for connection is finely tuned, and that’s a real strength. The trouble is that it tends to point outward. It reads his moods, his family, and his schedule, and it skips right over you. Your knowing is the strength, and saying it out loud is the skill. Something as simple as “I’d really love to spend Christmas with your family this year, how would you feel about that?” gives him a real chance to show up, especially when you say it early.
What It Feels Like to Get Curious Instead of Furious
Fair warning, speaking up early can feel wildly vulnerable at first, and the old habit will tug at you hardest when you’re already hurt. John Gottman studied couples in conflict and found that once your heart rate climbs past about 100 beats per minute, your body floods, and your ability to listen and problem solve drops off a cliff. Your heart races, your chest tightens, and the thoughtful, curious part of you goes offline. That’s usually when the three-times-drafted text gets sent. You can’t get curious when you’re furious, and a flooded body can only defend.
So the practice is a lot like stepping away from a half-built toy at midnight on Christmas Eve, when a screw is missing and somebody’s crying (probably you). Put the phone down, place a hand on your chest, and take a few slow breaths. Then ask yourself what you wanted, whether he knew you wanted it, and what you’re making it mean about you. From there the conversation softens into something like, “Oh my gosh, I just realized I would have loved to go to your mom’s for Christmas. Maybe we can plan something for next year?” It might feel awkward the first few times, and that wobbly feeling is your nervous system learning something new.
The Benefits of Writing Your Christmas List Out Loud
When you say the want first, you stop failing him on tests he never signed up for, and you skip a whole lot of fighting about the fight. Gottman also found that the first three minutes of a conversation predict how it will end about 96% of the time. Opening with a warm, early request instead of a hurt-filled accusation changes the whole ending of the story (and probably the whole mood of Christmas Eve).
You also get really clear information. How he responds when you share a want tells you so much. If he brushes it off with “babe, it’s not that big of a deal,” that’s a red flag worth paying attention to. If he says, “You know what, when I was at my mom’s I kind of wished you were there too,” you’ve found a man who can dance with you. Either way, you stop guessing, and over time you start healing the part of you that learned love had to be guessed at. 💛
Your Holiday Homework, Ladies
This season, the work is yours (in the best possible way). Notice the quiet hopes before they turn into big hurts. Ask yourself what you want this season. Maybe that’s exchanging gifts, meeting his friends at a holiday party, or a quiet night in with just the two of you. Get specific, then say it early, long before the day arrives.
Your hurt is real, and it’s also information pointing toward something you wanted and never said out loud. Wanting to be included, chosen, and seated at his family table is beautifully human. So write your list, regulate before you speak, and watch who shows up. And if you want scripts, somatic affirmations, and journal prompts to practice this all season long, grab Dance of Attachment on Audible (yep, that’s my voice reading it, so it’s like having me in your ear on the drive to grandma’s house).
